How To Choose The Best Ice Cream Maker For Home

How To Choose The Best Ice Cream Maker For Home

Choosing the best ice cream maker for your home means finding one that suits your needs, preferences and household size. With so many options available, it's worth considering what you'll be making and how often you'll use your ice cream machine before choosing your favourite. Our ice cream maker buying guide covers everything you need to know to make shopping easier, from the different types of ice cream makers available and the features to look for, to considering capacity, ease of use, cleaning and storage space, plus plenty more helpful tips.


Shop Ice Cream Makers




Quick Links




Types Of Home Ice Cream Machines

There are different types of home ice cream machines available, so choosing the right one for your kitchen is important. Consider how often you'll use it, your household size and the features that best suit your needs.

Freezer-Bowl Ice Cream Makers

Freezer-bowl ice cream makers use a removable bowl that needs to be frozen before making your ice cream. The frozen bowl helps chill the mixture as it churns, while an aluminium mixing bowl helps maintain consistent temperatures during churning, supporting smooth, evenly frozen results throughout your batch.

Ice Cream Makers With Compressors

Ice cream makers with compressors have built-in cooling systems that chill the mixture as it churns, removing the need for pre-freezing a bowl. This makes them a convenient choice when you want to make ice cream whenever the craving strikes, while supporting efficient performance and consistent results with less preparation.


Is An Ice Cream Maker With A Compressor Worth It?

An ice cream maker with a compressor is worth considering if you love making homemade ice cream regularly. Its built-in cooling system means there's no need to pre-freeze the bowl, making preparation easier and more convenient. It can also support consistent churning and cooling, helping you create smooth, delicious batches with less fuss.


Manual Ice Cream Makers

Manual ice cream makers are essentially ice cream makers that aren't electric, giving you a simple, hands-on way to create homemade treats. They come in different styles, such as models with handles for manually churning the mixture. They're a practical choice for enjoying homemade ice cream without relying on electricity.


Which Type Of Ice Cream Maker Is Best For You?

Consider which type of ice cream maker is best suited to your home and household. For example, would a smaller ice cream maker be enough for your household size, or would an ice cream maker with a compressor be more suitable for making more batches frequently? Think about your household needs, how often you plan to use it and your available kitchen space.




What Features Should You Look For In An Ice Cream Machine?

Choosing the best ice cream maker can make whipping up homemade treats so much easier. Before you buy, consider features that suit your needs, such as whether you want an ice cream maker with a compressor, a freezer-bowl design or even a soft serve ice cream machine for home.

Simple Controls

Simple controls are a handy feature to look for in an ice cream machine, especially if you're new to making homemade ice cream. Intuitive buttons, clear settings and easy-to-read controls make selecting your preferred setting simple, helping you start, monitor and finish each batch without complicated instructions or confusing functions.


Digital Displays

A digital display is another handy feature to look for in an ice cream maker, giving you a clear view of settings, timings and progress. This makes it easier to monitor your batch at a glance, adjust settings when needed and keep track of your ice cream without guesswork.


Preset Programmes

Preset programmes can make ice cream machines wonderfully simple to use, especially when you want delicious results without fiddling with settings. With pre-programmed options for different frozen treats, you can simply select the programme you need and let the machine handle the timing and settings, making homemade ice cream more convenient.


Timers

Timers are another useful feature to consider when choosing the best ice cream maker, helping you keep track of how long your dessert has been churning. A built-in timer can make the process more convenient by letting you know when your batch is ready, so you can focus on other tasks while it works its magic!


Automatic Shut-Off

Automatic shut-off is a useful feature to look for in an ice cream machine, giving you extra convenience and peace of mind. Once your selected programme or cycle is complete, the ice cream machine can switch off automatically, helping prevent over-processing and allowing you to get on with other tasks while your dessert is prepared.


Consistency Sensors

Consistency sensors are a clever feature found in some ice cream makers, designed to monitor the thickness of your mixture as it churns. By detecting changes in consistency, the ice cream machine can adjust its operation or indicate when your ice cream has reached the desired texture, helping make homemade treats easier.


Transparent Lids

Transparent lids are a great feature to look for in an ice cream machine, as they let you keep an eye on your mixture while it churns. It allows you to simply look through the lid to monitor how your ice cream is progressing, check its consistency, and see when it's getting closer to ready.


Ingredient Chutes

An ingredient chute is a useful feature for home ice cream makers, making it easy to add extra ingredients while your mixture is churning. You can conveniently add chocolate chips, nuts, fruit or other favourite mix-ins without stopping the machine, helping you create delicious flavours with minimal fuss and mess.




Which Ice Cream Maker Capacity Should You Choose?

When it comes to ice cream maker capacity, you'll need to think about how many people you'll usually be serving and how often you make homemade ice cream. Small ice cream makers suit couples or smaller households, while larger ice cream machines are handy for families and entertaining. Remember to check the machine's stated capacity and avoid overfilling the bowl during use.


Bowl Capacity Vs Actual Ice Cream Yield

When choosing an ice cream maker, remember that bowl capacity isn't always the same as your final ice cream yield. The mixture expands as it churns, so you shouldn't fill the bowl to the brim. Check the manufacturer's recommended maximum fill level and stated yield to understand how much ice cream you'll actually make.




How Much Bench And Storage Space Do You Need?

It's essential to consider how much kitchen bench and storage space you have available when choosing an ice cream maker for your home. Check the machine's overall dimensions, including its height, width, and depth, to ensure it fits comfortably where you'll use it. Also consider its weight, cord storage and whether the bowl or accessories can be stored neatly in your kitchen cupboards between uses.




How Much Freezer Space Will You Need?

It's also important to consider how much freezer space you'll need when buying a new ice cream machine - particularly if you're choosing a freezer-bowl model. These ice cream machines require the bowl to be frozen before use, so check its size and make sure you have enough room in your freezer. Remember to account for the bowl's height and storage position.


Does The Ice Cream Maker Bowl Need To Be Frozen?

Freezer-bowl ice cream makers need a pre-frozen bowl because the bowl provides the cold temperature needed to freeze your ice cream mixture as it churns. Freezing the bowl beforehand ensures it's cold enough to help transform your liquid mixture into smooth, creamy ice cream while the machine operates.


Will The Bowl Fit In Your Freezer?

Before purchasing a freezer-bowl ice cream maker, measure the available space in your freezer and compare it with the bowl's dimensions. Check the bowl's height, width and shape, allowing extra room around it if needed. Don't forget to consider shelves, drawers and other items that could restrict where the bowl can sit.




How Powerful Does An Ice Cream Maker Need To Be?

When comparing ice cream makers, consider the motor power alongside the type and amount of ice cream you'll make. Higher-powered ice cream machines can handle thicker mixtures and larger batches more easily, while small ice cream makers may suit occasional home use. Check the manufacturer's recommendations for capacity and ingredients, rather than choosing based on wattage alone.


Does Higher Wattage Mean Better Ice Cream?

Higher wattage doesn't necessarily mean better ice cream. While a more powerful motor can help handle thicker mixtures and larger batches, other factors also affect your results, including churning speed, temperature control and the machine's design. When comparing ice cream machines for your home, consider the overall features and performance rather than focusing on wattage alone.




Ice Cream Machine Safety Features To Consider

Safety is always worth considering when choosing an ice cream machine for your home. From secure lids and automatic shut-off to overload protection, the right safety features can make operation easier and give you extra peace of mind while creating homemade frozen treats.

Lid-Lock Mechanisms

Lid-lock mechanisms are an important safety feature to consider, particularly in homes with children. A secure locking system helps keep the lid firmly in place while the ice cream machine operates, reducing the risk of accidental opening. Look for models with clearly indicated locks that are simple to use.


Automatic Shut-Off

Automatic shut-off is an important safety feature in an ice cream machine, helping prevent the appliance from continuing to operate once a cycle is complete. It can reduce unnecessary running time and gives you added peace of mind if you're busy or briefly step away.


Overheating Protection

Overheating protection helps to protect the ice cream machine's motor if it becomes too hot during operation. The machine can detect excessive heat and pause or stop automatically, reducing the risk of damage. This provides added peace of mind when making homemade ice cream.


Non-Slip Feet

Non-slip feet are an easily overlooked safety feature when buying an ice cream maker, but they can make a difference during operation. They help keep the machine securely positioned on your kitchen bench, reducing unwanted movement and helping prevent accidental slips or knocks while your ice cream is churning.




Shop Quality Ice Cream Machines At Harris Scarfe Today

Shop for the best ice cream makers in Australia at Harris Scarfe! Explore our entire range of ice cream makers, as well as novelty & snack makers, blenders, scoops, utensils & gadgets and much more to find the ideal ice cream machine for your home.

Make sure to visit us online or in-store, and if you enjoyed our guide on how to choose the best ice cream maker for your kitchen, then head over to our Food Hub for more helpful cooking and baking blogs! Some great articles you'll love include:

share