How To Choose The Best Frypan: Frypan & Skillet Buying Guide

How To Choose The Best Frypan: Frypan & Skillet Buying Guide

Choosing the right type of frypan is an important decision for any kitchen. To get the best results, you need to consider key factors such as your cooktop, your cooking style and how you plan to use the pan day to day. The right choice can make cooking easier, more efficient and far more enjoyable.

In this frying pan and skillet buying guide, we'll walk you through all the important factors you need to consider so you can confidently choose the best frying pan for your kitchen.




Quick Links




How To Choose The Best Type Of Frying Pan

With the many different types of frying pans out there on the market, it can be difficult to choose the right one for your kitchen and how you like to cook. In this section, we will break down the main types of frying pans so you can choose the best one for you!

Classic Frying Pan

Choosing the right frying pan for your kitchen starts with understanding how you cook and what you cook most often. The main things to consider are the material, as this affects heat distribution and performance, your cooktop type, especially if you use induction, the size and depth of the pan for your typical meal, and the weight, which impacts handling and heat retention. You should also look at handle design for comfort and durability, as well as overall construction quality.

Skillet

Consider the material first, as this affects heat retention and responsiveness. Stainless steel is great for searing, non-stick suits delicate foods and cast iron offers excellent heat retention. Next, check the size to ensure it fits your stovetop and typical portion sizes. Make sure it's compatible with your cooktop, especially if you use induction. Finally, look for a sturdy, comfortable handle and solid construction for long-term durability and performance.

Saute Pan

Focus on factors that match your cooking style and consider the material, as it affects heat distribution and retention. Stainless steel is ideal for even cooking, while non-stick is easier for delicate foods. Look at the size and depth to accommodate the dishes you cook most. Check for a heavy, flat base to prevent hot spots, a comfortable handle for safe handling, and lids for moisture control. Also, ensure it's compatible with your cooktop, including induction if needed.

Wok

Choosing a wok for your kitchen starts with thinking about the material: carbon steel woks heat quickly and develop a natural non-stick patina, while stainless steel is more durable and easier to maintain. Look at the size and shape to suit your stovetop and the portions you cook. Check for a sturdy, comfortable handle and, if possible, a lid for steaming. Finally, ensure the wok is compatible with your cooktop, especially induction or flat-surfaced stoves.

Grill Pan

Choosing a grill pan starts with considering how you like to cook. Look for a material that suits your style: cast iron offers excellent heat retention and searing, while non-stick makes cooking and cleaning easier. Size and shape are important to fit your stovetop and accommodate the foods you usually prepare. Check for sturdy, comfortable handles and, if relevant, ridges for grill marks. Finally, make sure the pan is compatible with your cooktop, including induction, gas or electric surfaces.



What Is The Best Frying Pan Material?

With so many different frying pan materials available, it can be tricky to know which one is right for you. Each material offers unique benefits, from heat retention to ease of cleaning, and choosing the wrong type can affect your cooking results. In the next section, we'll break down the main types of frying pan materials, explaining their features and advantages, so you can make an informed decision and select the best frying pan to suit your kitchen and cooking style.

Non-Stick Frying Pans

For non-stick frying pans, PTFE-coated (Teflon) aluminium is widely regarded as one of the best materials. The aluminium base heats quickly and distributes heat evenly, while the PTFE coating provides a smooth, slick surface that prevents food from sticking. This combination is especially ideal for cooking delicate foods like eggs, fish or crepes, which can easily break apart on other surfaces. High-quality PTFE coatings are designed to be long-lasting and durable, making non-stick frying pans a reliable choice for effortless cooking and easy cleaning.


Stainless Steel Frying Pans

The best material for stainless steel frying pans combines high-quality stainless steel with multi-ply construction. Look for 18/10 or 18/8 stainless steel, which offers excellent durability, corrosion resistance and a non-reactive cooking surface. Ideally, the pan should feature 3-ply or 5-ply construction, with layers of aluminium or copper sandwiched between stainless steel. This ensures even heat distribution, prevents hot spots and provides better temperature control, making it perfect for searing, sautéing, and everyday cooking while maintaining long-lasting performance.


Cast Iron Frying Pans

The best material for cast iron frying pans is enamelled cast iron. Unlike traditional bare cast iron, the enamel coating prevents rust and eliminates the need for seasoning, making it easier to maintain. It still offers excellent heat retention and even cooking, perfect for searing, frying and slow cooking. The smooth enamel surface also allows for easier cleaning and is non-reactive, meaning it won't affect the taste of acidic foods like tomatoes or wine-based sauces, making it a versatile and durable choice.


Carbon Steel Frying Pans

The best material for traditional cast iron frying pans is made from approximately 99% iron and 1% carbon. This specific composition is important because the high iron content provides excellent heat retention and even cooking, while the small amount of carbon strengthens the metal, making it durable and resistant to warping. This combination allows the pan to withstand high temperatures, develop a natural non-stick surface with seasoning, and deliver consistent, reliable cooking performance, making it ideal for searing, frying, and slow-cooking tasks.


Ceramic Frying Pans

The best material for ceramic frying pans is going to be hard-anodised aluminium, which is both durable and highly resistant to warping. Its excellent heat conductivity ensures the pan heats evenly, preventing hot spots that can affect cooking results. This even heat distribution also helps the ceramic coating perform at its best, providing reliable non-stick cooking for delicate foods. Hard-anodised aluminium's strength and stability make ceramic frying pans long-lasting, efficient and easy to use, making them a practical and high-performing choice for everyday cooking.




How Does Your Stove Type Affect Your Frypan Choice

Understanding how your frying pan interacts with your stovetop is essential to choosing the best pan for your kitchen. The right material and design ensure efficient heat transfer, even cooking and safe, hassle-free use. In this section, we'll cover everything you need to know about stovetop compatibility, including which frying pans work best on gas, electric, ceramic and induction cooktops, helping you make an informed and confident choice.


Best Frypan For Gas Stoves

The best frypans for gas stoves are those that can handle high heat and distribute it evenly. Heavy-bottomed stainless-steel frypans (ideally with 3-ply construction) are excellent choices because they provide even heat distribution, prevent hot spots and are durable enough for regular high-heat cooking.

Cast iron frying pans are another top option, thanks to their exceptional heat retention and ability to maintain a steady temperature, making them perfect for searing meat and achieving a beautiful, perfect crust. Both options give you control and reliability, ensuring professional-quality results on a gas stove.


Best Frypan For Induction Stoves

The best frypan for induction stoves must be magnetic, as induction cooktops work by generating heat directly in the pan through magnetic fields. This means only materials that are magnetic (like cast iron, carbon steel or magnetic stainless steel) will work effectively. Choosing a non-magnetic frypan will prevent it from heating at all.

The easiest way to ensure compatibility is to check the product description before purchasing. Look for a clear statement that the frypan is suitable for induction cooktops, or verify that it features the induction compatibility symbol, giving you confidence that it will perform perfectly.


Best Frypan For Electric Stoves

The best frypans for electric stoves are those that heat evenly and retain heat well. Stainless steel frypans with an aluminium core, cast iron or hard-anodised aluminium are top choices because these materials provide excellent heat distribution and stability, preventing hot spots while cooking.

On electric cooktops, even heating is crucial for consistent results, especially with slow-cooked or delicate foods. Choosing a frypan with a heavy base is also important, as it helps prevent warping over time, even with frequent use, ensuring your pan remains flat, stable, and reliable for years of cooking.


Best Pan That Is Oven-Safe

The best type of frying pan for oven use is one made from durable materials like cast iron, carbon steel, or high-quality stainless steel, as these can withstand high temperatures (typically around 260 C) without warping, melting or losing performance. Oven-safe frypans allow you to sear on the stovetop and finish cooking in the oven, adding versatility to your kitchen.

The easiest way to confirm if a frying pan is suitable for oven use is to check the product description carefully. Look for a clear label stating it is oven-safe, ensuring you can cook confidently without risking damage.




How To Assess The Frying Pan Construction

Before buying a frying pan, it's important to assess its construction carefully. The materials, thickness and layering all affect how the frying pan heats up, retains heat and performs during cooking. By understanding these aspects, you can ensure that the frying pan meets your cooking needs, delivers consistent results and will last for years, making it a reliable addition to your kitchen.


Is "Clad" Construction Worth The Extra Cost?

Clad construction in frying pans is generally worth the extra cost if you value durability, longevity, and superior cooking performance. A clad pan features layers of different metals, often aluminium or copper, sandwiched between stainless steel, which provides even heat distribution and reduces hot spots. This means food cooks more consistently and with better results.

Additionally, clad pans tend to be sturdier and more resistant to warping or damage over time. If your priority is reliable, long-lasting cookware that delivers professional-quality results, investing in a clad frying pan can be a smart choice for your kitchen.


How Thick Should The Pan Be For Good Heat Distribution?

For good heat distribution, the thickness of a frypan is a key factor. Ideally, a frying pan's base should be between 3mm and 5mm thick. This added thickness helps prevent hot spots, ensuring that food cooks evenly across the entire surface, and reduces the risk of warping over time - even with regular high-heat use.

Frypans with bases under 2mm thick are much more susceptible to warping, which can affect cooking performance and longevity. Choosing a frying pan with a properly thick base ensures consistent, reliable results and a longer-lasting, durable piece of cookware for your kitchen.


What Frypan Handle Features Matter Most?

When choosing a new frypan, the handle is more than just a grip - it directly affects safety, comfort, and durability. You'll want to look for handles with an ergonomic design that fits comfortably in your hand, reducing strain during cooking. Stay-cool handles are also essential, allowing you to move and lift the pan safely without risking burns.

Additionally, riveted handles provide superior strength compared to screwed-on handles, ensuring the handle remains secure even with frequent use. Focusing on these features helps you handle your frypan confidently while cooking and ensures it lasts for years.




Choosing The Right Size Frypan

When choosing the right size frypan for your kitchen, consider both your household size and the types of meals you cook most often. A 26cm frypan is ideal for smaller households or preparing meals for one to two people, offering easy handling and efficient heating. For families or larger households, a 30cm frypan provides more cooking surface, allowing you to cook multiple portions at once.

The most important factor is matching the frypan size to your cooking needs, ensuring it's large enough to prepare your typical meals comfortably, without overcrowding or uneven cooking.

What Size Frypan Should You Buy First?

If you're buying your first frypan, the best size to start with is a 26cm skillet. This size offers the ideal balance for cooking meals for one to three people, making it versatile for everyday use without being too large or cumbersome. A 26cm pan heats evenly, is easy to handle and fits comfortably on most stovetops, making it perfect for beginners or anyone looking to cover most cooking needs without investing in multiple sizes right away.




Is It Worth Buying A Frying Pan Set?

If you're moving into a new home or upgrading your entire cookware collection from scratch, investing in a frypan set can be well worth it. Frypan sets are excellent because they provide a range of sizes, ensuring you have the right pan for every cooking task, from small meals to family-sized dishes.

Beyond functionality, a coordinated frypan set offers a cohesive and uniform look in your kitchen, keeping your cookware stylish as well as practical. Choosing a matching set simplifies meal prep, saves shopping time and gives your kitchen a polished and organised appearance.



Shop Quality Frypans & Skillets At Harris Scarfe Today

The best type of frypan for your kitchen should fit your cooking needs, budget and style, and at Harris Scarfe, we have an incredible selection of frypans and skillets that is sure to tick all your boxes. With a wide selection of cookware, pots, roasters, cookware sets and much more, you have heaps of flexibility and choice. Discover our extensive frying pan range online and in-store at Harris Scarfe today.


Shop Frying Pans

share